
US Release: July 1971 (Motown MS 723)
UK Release: October 1971 (Tamla Motown 11193
Track Listing
Surrender
Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You
Remember Me
And If You See Him
Reach Out I’ll Be There
Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime
A Simple Thing Like Cry
Did You Read The Morning Paper?
I’ll Settle For You
I’m A Winner
All The Befores
Chart Positions: UK #10 (certified Silver seller) US Billboard R&B #10 Canada #45 US Billboard Pop #56
Singles Released from Surrender:

US Release: 8 December 1970 (Motown MS 1176)
UK Release: 26 March 1971 (Tamla Motown TMG 768)
Chart Positions: UK #7 US Cash Box #8 Canada #9 US Billboard R&B #10 US Billboard Pop #16 (certified Gold seller) US Billboard Adult Contemporary #20
Year-end Charts (1971): UK #72 US Cash Box #75 US Joel Whitburn’s Pop Annual #133

US Release Date: April 1971 (Motown MS 1184)
Chart Positions: US Billboard Adult contemporary #16 US Billboard R&B #17 US Billboard Pop #29 Canada #35

US Release: 29 July 1971 (Motown MS 1188)
UK Release: 22 October 1971 (Tamla Motown TMG 792)
Chart Positions: UK #10 US Billboard R&B #16 US Billboard Pop #38 Canada #45

In early 1971, Diana Ross, now fully established as an all-round show-woman, starred in her first solo television special, Diana! A Motown production, it was screened on both sides of the Atlantic, first airing on ABC-TV on 18 April 1971 in the US and screened by BBC2 five months later in the UK. The TV special ratings soared through the roof, but sales for the soundtrack proved relatively disappointing; it crept in at #46 on the US chart, despite its runaway success in terms of television ratings, and hit the R&B top three. On a more positive side, Diana! went on to scoop the award for Best TV Special of The Year.

Eager to keep up the momentum of Diana Ross’ solo career, Berry Gordy appointed Ashford & Simpson as writers and producers for her third solo studio project, sessions beginning in August 1970 and was finally completed in early 1971, following the success of Ain’t No Mountain High Enough and prior to the release of the more commercial Everything Is Everything.
Valerie Simpson recalled to David Nathan in the notes to the 2008 Surrender: Expanded Edition: “The fact that we had a number-one hit record out of the first album meant that Berry Gordy just gave us another album to do. Berry showed a great deal of faith in us. He didn’t know what we were doing…he just let us go for it. If there was something we weren’t sure of, we’d send a demo over to Diana, but it wasn’t until we had laid tracks for the song. There was a certain degree of trust between us—we’d come to know each other from the first album, and it was like a marriage.”

Simpson would also write in the liner notes: “Diana Ross was probably the hardest worker of any of the people we worked with at Motown. She was always prepared, ready, early, on time.”

Ashford & Simpson always knew how to craft the very best records for Motown’s leading lady. Culled from these August-September 1970 sessions was Diana’s third solo single, Remember Me, released at the end of the year. Remember Me was originally conceived as a vehicle for its co-writer/producer, Valerie Simpson, who recorded it for her debut solo album Exposed, in which Diana Ross wrote the liner notes. In fact, Valerie’s album and Surrender by Diana were promoted by Motown together, with Billboard magazine running a front-page advertisement that read: ‘Diana = Valerie, a mutual admiration society’. But Berry Gordy was adamant the song should be that all-important follow-up to Ain’t No Mountain High Enough.

Soulful and haunting, Remember Me was cradled with mixed emotions. The lyrics depict a woman who’s courageously waving goodbye to her former lover, insisting he remember all the good times they’ve had together. Tinged with sadness, the song could almost have been a direct message to her mentor and one-time lover Berry Gordy. (Their love affair ended that year when Diana married Robert Silberstein, later known as Bob Ellis.) Diana has always been impeccable with her astute, heartfelt interpretations of lyrics, yet it sounds here as though something’s stirring up the hidden emotions in her. With a voice pouring with anguish, she adds to the flourishing arrangement by Paul Riser, which leads to an exalting, classical-like crescendo containing an urgent rush of strings and horns.
Backed with How About You from Everything Is Everything as the B-side, the single flew into the Top 20 on the Billboard Hot 100, and stormed into the R&B Top 10. In the UK, where most of Diana’s first batch of solo singles had been better received than they were in America, it shot to #7, enjoying a three-month run on the chart. This undoubtedly ranks as one of Diana’s all-time best classics.



For her fourth solo single, Ashford & Simpson blatantly attempted to rework the formula of Diana’s blockbuster Ain’t No Mountain High Enough. They disassembled The Four Tops’ 1967 chart-topper Reach Out I’ll Be There, written, produced and composed by Holland-Dozier-Holland. Although not quite managing to recapture the full momentum of Ain’t No Mountain High Enough—which, let’s face it, isn’t an easy task to accomplish—this stunning reworking is deeper and darker than the original. Her vocals are at their most gutsy and soulful as she lags behind the beat while retaining full command, and the backing harmonies are dreamy and hypnotic, seamlessly melting into the backdrop. Like Ain’t No Mountain High Enough, the track leads to a rousing climax after a gradual build-up, the tension escalating in Diana’s voice as she’s joined by roaring gospel harmonies. Released in April 1971, with (They Long To Be) Close To You as the flip, the single should have been a far bigger success than it was. Anchoring at #29 in the US Pop chart and #17 in the R&B chart, it was a huge disappointment, considering its quality and excellence.

Three months later, the upbeat American title track Surrender was lifted and was sorely underrated at the time. Here, the track steers much more toward pure R&B rather than her usual pop-soul sound. Constructed in two parts, the quirky verses lead to an Ain’t No Mountain High Enough-style chorus (coincidentally, Ashford & Simpson were working on this title around the time the song hit the top of the pop and R&B charts. Diana sounds a little raw and far earthier as opposed to her familiar vocal approach, sinking her teeth into the material and delivering a fiery, far more aggressive performance than she ever had before.

Commencing with vociferous piano playing and a slamming percussive beat, the track erupts into a thunderous climax, featuring Diana at her most soulful as she belts out ad-libs. At this early stage in her solo career she had developed something of a penchant for melodrama, which brought out the character and drama in her voice. With Diana having such a broad pop fan base, it seemed radio airplay was inconsistent. While some major stations seldom played the song, other areas added it to their Top 10 lists, so opinion was divided. This inconsistency resulted in the single stalling at just #38 on the Billboard chart and an R&B #16. Yet British audiences, once again, were far more appreciative, taking the song up into the Top 10. Valerie Simpson concluded that she thought it may have been too soulful to cross over to become a big pop hit. Even though Diana was delighted with her British success, she couldn’t help but feel disheartened at the lack of support in her home country.
She commented at a press conference at the time: “I wasn’t too happy with the way some of the records weren’t as big as we’d hoped. I was disappointed Surrender didn’t happen the way I’d have liked. Of course, you don’t expect everything to be a smash hit when it’s released as a single.”

The accompanying Surrender album, released in July 1971, is one of her most powerful, soulful and cohesive recording projects. Diana’s crystal-clear delivery is stretched, allowing her to cut loose and sing with an abandon she never really had before. The material was meatier and her vocals neatly surf Ashford & Simpson’s stunningly complex arrangements.
I Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You, which features an added writing contribution from Brian Holland, had been recorded by Kiki Dee and Motown recording artist Rita Wright (later more famously billed as Syreeta) in 1967. Diana’s version is much more fully formed, her pleading vocals complementing the floating orchestrations. She also recalls Ain’t No Mountain High Enough by delivering spoken passages that lead to a roaring climax.
Valerie Simpson’s piano work, the prominent bassline, swirling strings and booming horns accompany her, and Diana’s impassioned vocals are purely soulful at the grand, dramatic finale, Valerie describing her ad-libs as being in the stratosphere. Diana had recorded another excellent version of this song back in 1968 and was earmarked for The Supremes’ album Love Child. However, the backing vocals were never completed and didn’t see the light of day until the 2008 release Let The Music Play: Supremes Rarities 1960-1969/Motown Lost & Found. Valerie Simpson was quoted in the liner notes to the Expanded Edition: “It was Nick’s idea to revisit the song. Sometimes, you almost feel like you missed the mark and you don’t know why but you feel like the song has some potential so you try it again.”




And If You See Him is outstanding. Valerie described the song as being odd, as it starts in the middle of a sentence and picks up out of nowhere. The song seems to continue in the same softly reflective vein as Remember Me, opening with pulsing guitar and bass notes which sets a tone of urgency. As it leads into the swaying chorus, Diana’s double-tracked vocals rise in power while midway through the second verse she shifts her vocal pitch into the top end of her range. From that point on she sounds as if she’s in constant despair as the track drives into the racing bridge instrumental. Almost becoming manic at points, this merges as a stellar and thoroughly compelling album session, featuring Diana on a soulful high. The track had actually been first cut for Marvin Gaye with the song’s title being And If You See Her though Diana ended up recording her version first.
In Rolling Stone magazine’s review of Surrender in 1971, Russell Gersten took a particular liking to ‘And If You See Him’, highlighting in the article, writing it, “has the poignancy of the great early Motown songs like ‘You Beat Me To The Punch.’ The brilliant, but simple use of rhythm instruments, and the rapid shift of moods perfectly recreate the ambivalence and desperation of someone rejected.”


The format of Surrender is vaguely similar in its ethos and mood of Diana’s debut solo project. Like that album, the second half settles down into mellower sounds and textures that are brimming with rich and passionate performances. Previously recorded by Gladys Knight & The Pips, Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime swerves narrowly into more gospel-like territory, featuring a highly charged gospel backing on the chorus and Diana’s softer leads on the verses. Yet again the beginning of the track sounds smooth, sensitive, reflective and a little sensuous even and is succeeded by a grand, dazzling crescendo. Valerie wanted to improve upon the version she and Nick had done with Gladys Knight and the Pips, and they felt Diana’s version was better produced. In Billboard’s review of Surrender, they listed Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime, along with the title track and I Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You as being strong contenders for release as a single.


The gently rolling A Simple Thing Like Cry contains another stunning and soulful performance from Diana, ranking this as an exceptional album track. The song builds in tension, and Diana really hits her vocal peak in a track Valerie said encapsulated a jazzy feel. Beginning a subdued style, she lets rip as each of the verses climax into the chorus, demonstrating her true vocal power when she’s allowed to cut free.

Another highlight is served on the stirring, cinematic story-song Did You Read The Morning Paper? which, like A Simple Thing Like Cry, holds a swinging jazz vibe amidst the soulful instrumental. Blending a slamming piano line into the well-crafted jazz flavour, this story-song is beautifully coated by the lush, emotive vocals from Diana. The idea of the storyline concerning a woman’s cheating lover stemmed from Richard Monica’s work for Nancy Wilson on Guess Who I Saw Today. Diana’s interpretive skill really shines on compelling songs such as these.

Far mellower is the dreamy ballad I’ll Settle For You, which intentionally carries a more pop sound and is deceptively simple in melody. Diana displays her unique and effortless flair for ballads here, her enunciation being exquisite, her vocals low, breathy and seamless to then fully accelerating into the top end of her vocal range. The song had first been recorded by female group Candy & The Kisses back in the 1960s on the Scepter label. Valerie Simpson described I’ll Settle For You as “our ‘crossover’ song, in case white radio wanted to play something. Diana was one of those artists who really did cross over to pop.”

The funky I’m A Winner, the B-side to Surrender, has Las Vegas written all over it. First recorded by Martha Reeves and the Vandellas on their Sugar n Spice album in 1969, Diana bites into the jamming arrangement, giving all she’s got. Her fun, sassy and forceful delivery steadily grows stronger throughout the track, sounding impressively razor sharp as she hits those high notes towards the climax of this belter. Interestingly, after the Martha Reeves & The Vandellas’ original, it was then assigned to Edwin Starr with the backing track made at the same time as Diana’s first solo album. It was only when the sessions for Surrender were under way that it was passed to Diana to record. Billboard magazine also declared this as a highlight of the album in their review.

The album then winds down gently with the glorious All The Befores, which was quite an unusual composition from Ashford & Simpson, though fitted Diana perfectly. Much of Diana’s music has a special, soothing, therapeutic quality, and never more so than on this beautifully delivered ballad, which is nothing short of a masterpiece. The haunting tone is set by a dramatic, classical-like arrangement, with piano and strings leading the way as Diana sings in a more subdued manner, which still emerges as soulful. Her silky yet assertive vocals spiral in front of the music during each verse, flowing seamlessly into the chorus. It’s an excellent end to an essential Diana Ross album.

Surrender is a classic album in the diva’s extensive catalogue, capturing her in strongly emotive voice throughout, complementing Ashford & Simpson’s compositions immensely. Unlike Everything Is Everything, which lacked consistency, this had been carefully conceived as a full studio project and isn’t interrupted by any mediocre fillers. On a personal note, this ranks as one of my favourites by Diana, as her singing is more powerful and engaging than ever; the mood shifts from funky soul to jazzy soul and to out-and-out soul. Excellence all the way.

Although Surrender wasn’t a huge seller in the US, dipping at #56, although did hit the R&B Top 10, sales in the UK were fuelled by the success of the two singles Surrender and Remember Me, elevating it to #10 on the album listing. Incidentally, Surrender was retitled I’m Still Waiting for the British market, to cash in on that track’s chart-topping success that year, even though it had originally been recorded as an additional track for Everything Is Everything.

In late 2008, Surrender was reissued on CD with additional tracks: the delightful Baby I’ll Come (first recorded by Mary Love on the Kent label), Remember Me (Diana! Vocal/undubbed stereo mixed versions and two other alternative mixes); Reach Out I’ll Be There and I Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You, both alternate versions and Ain’t No Mountain High Enough and Surrender, both alternative mixes.

In an interview with David Nathan, she spoke about her more powerful singing which she had developed by this time: “A lot of things had happened to me by then. And I’m sure I was probably reflecting that. I had gotten married by then, and I was really going through changes in my life. You know, there are peak points in your life where you’re having a real learning experience and a real change. A lot of things were happening to me in the early 1970s, and I think, in a sense, it was frightening…leaving the girls…but there was a freedom, a freeing of me. It’s just like I was beginning to trust myself more as a singer. I was gaining much more confidence and to trust, and I think that may have shown through, too.”



In late 1971 was the honorary chairman of the Image Awards Presentation. She was also voted number-one entertainer of the year by the NAACP.

In February 1972, Diana was voted the top female singer of 1971 by readers of the weekly music newspaper Disc & Music Echo. Unable to be interviewed, Diana sent a telegraphed reply: “I’m deeply touched by the honor bestowed upon me being selected Disc & Music Echo‘s World’s Leading Female Singer for 1971. Because I’m winding up the filming of Lady Sings The Blues, I regret not being able to attend the awards presentation. You have my sincere best wishes for a successful affair. Affectionately yours, Diana Ross.”





In November 1972, as there were no new studio projects, a compilation simply titled Greatest Hits burst into the UK chart. It contained Diana’s hit singles to date, as well as some outstanding tracks, including And If You See Him, How About You, Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime and (They Long To Be) Close To You.






































































