Her Classic Third Solo Album: Written & Produced By Ashford & Simpson

US Release: July 1971 (Motown MS 723)

UK Release: October 1971 (Tamla Motown 11193

Track Listing

Surrender

Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You

Remember Me

And If You See Him

Reach Out I’ll Be There

Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime

A Simple Thing Like Cry

Did You Read The Morning Paper?

I’ll Settle For You

I’m A Winner

All The Befores

Chart Positions: UK #10 (certified Silver seller) US Billboard R&B #10 Canada #45 US Billboard Pop #56

Singles Released from Surrender:

US Release: 8 December 1970 (Motown MS 1176)

UK Release: 26 March 1971 (Tamla Motown TMG 768)

Chart Positions: UK #7 US Cash Box #8 Canada #9 US Billboard R&B #10 US Billboard Pop #16 (certified Gold seller) US Billboard Adult Contemporary #20

Year-end Charts (1971): UK #72 US Cash Box #75 US Joel Whitburn’s Pop Annual #133

US Release Date: April 1971 (Motown MS 1184)

Chart Positions: US Billboard Adult contemporary #16 US Billboard R&B #17 US Billboard Pop #29 Canada #35

US Release: 29 July 1971 (Motown MS 1188)

UK Release: 22 October 1971 (Tamla Motown TMG 792)

Chart Positions: UK #10 US Billboard R&B #16 US Billboard Pop #38 Canada #45

In early 1971, Diana Ross, now fully established as an all-round show-woman, starred in her first solo television special, Diana! A Motown production, it was screened on both sides of the Atlantic, first airing on ABC-TV on 18 April 1971 in the US and screened by BBC2 five months later in the UK. The TV special ratings soared through the roof, but sales for the soundtrack proved relatively disappointing; it crept in at #46 on the US chart, despite its runaway success in terms of television ratings, and hit the R&B top three. On a more positive side, Diana! went on to scoop the award for Best TV Special of The Year.

Eager to keep up the momentum of Diana Ross’ solo career, Berry Gordy appointed Ashford & Simpson as writers and producers for her third solo studio project, sessions beginning in August 1970 and was finally completed in early 1971, following the success of Ain’t No Mountain High Enough and prior to the release of the more commercial Everything Is Everything.

Valerie Simpson recalled to David Nathan in the notes to the 2008 Surrender: Expanded Edition: “The fact that we had a number-one hit record out of the first album meant that Berry Gordy just gave us another album to do. Berry showed a great deal of faith in us. He didn’t know what we were doing…he just let us go for it. If there was something we weren’t sure of, we’d send a demo over to Diana, but it wasn’t until we had laid tracks for the song. There was a certain degree of trust between us—we’d come to know each other from the first album, and it was like a marriage.”

Simpson would also write in the liner notes: “Diana Ross was probably the hardest worker of any of the people we worked with at Motown.  She was always prepared, ready, early, on time.” 

Ashford & Simpson always knew how to craft the very best records for Motown’s leading lady. Culled from these August-September 1970 sessions was Diana’s third solo single, Remember Me, released at the end of the year. Remember Me was originally conceived as a vehicle for its co-writer/producer, Valerie Simpson, who recorded it for her debut solo album Exposed, in which Diana Ross wrote the liner notes. In fact, Valerie’s album and Surrender by Diana were promoted by Motown together, with Billboard magazine running a front-page advertisement that read: ‘Diana = Valerie, a mutual admiration society’. But Berry Gordy was adamant the song should be that all-important follow-up to Ain’t No Mountain High Enough.

Soulful and haunting, Remember Me was cradled with mixed emotions. The lyrics depict a woman who’s courageously waving goodbye to her former lover, insisting he remember all the good times they’ve had together. Tinged with sadness, the song could almost have been a direct message to her mentor and one-time lover Berry Gordy. (Their love affair ended that year when Diana married Robert Silberstein, later known as Bob Ellis.) Diana has always been impeccable with her astute, heartfelt interpretations of lyrics, yet it sounds here as though something’s stirring up the hidden emotions in her. With a voice pouring with anguish, she adds to the flourishing arrangement by Paul Riser, which leads to an exalting, classical-like crescendo containing an urgent rush of strings and horns.

Backed with How About You from Everything Is Everything as the B-side, the single flew into the Top 20 on the Billboard Hot 100, and stormed into the R&B Top 10. In the UK, where most of Diana’s first batch of solo singles had been better received than they were in America, it shot to #7, enjoying a three-month run on the chart. This undoubtedly ranks as one of Diana’s all-time best classics.

For her fourth solo single, Ashford & Simpson blatantly attempted to rework the formula of Diana’s blockbuster Ain’t No Mountain High Enough. They disassembled The Four Tops’ 1967 chart-topper Reach Out I’ll Be There, written, produced and composed by Holland-Dozier-Holland. Although not quite managing to recapture the full momentum of Ain’t No Mountain High Enough—which, let’s face it, isn’t an easy task to accomplish—this stunning reworking is deeper and darker than the original. Her vocals are at their most gutsy and soulful as she lags behind the beat while retaining full command, and the backing harmonies are dreamy and hypnotic, seamlessly melting into the backdrop. Like Ain’t No Mountain High Enough, the track leads to a rousing climax after a gradual build-up, the tension escalating in Diana’s voice as she’s joined by roaring gospel harmonies. Released in April 1971, with (They Long To Be) Close To You as the flip, the single should have been a far bigger success than it was. Anchoring at #29 in the US Pop chart and #17 in the R&B chart, it was a huge disappointment, considering its quality and excellence.

Three months later, the upbeat American title track Surrender was lifted and was sorely underrated at the time. Here, the track steers much more toward pure R&B rather than her usual pop-soul sound. Constructed in two parts, the quirky verses lead to an Ain’t No Mountain High Enough-style chorus (coincidentally, Ashford & Simpson were working on this title around the time the song hit the top of the pop and R&B charts. Diana sounds a little raw and far earthier as opposed to her familiar vocal approach, sinking her teeth into the material and delivering a fiery, far more aggressive performance than she ever had before.

Commencing with vociferous piano playing and a slamming percussive beat, the track erupts into a thunderous climax, featuring Diana at her most soulful as she belts out ad-libs. At this early stage in her solo career she had developed something of a penchant for melodrama, which brought out the character and drama in her voice. With Diana having such a broad pop fan base, it seemed radio airplay was inconsistent. While some major stations seldom played the song, other areas added it to their Top 10 lists, so opinion was divided. This inconsistency resulted in the single stalling at just #38 on the Billboard chart and an R&B #16. Yet British audiences, once again, were far more appreciative, taking the song up into the Top 10. Valerie Simpson concluded that she thought it may have been too soulful to cross over to become a big pop hit. Even though Diana was delighted with her British success, she couldn’t help but feel disheartened at the lack of support in her home country.

She commented at a press conference at the time: “I wasn’t too happy with the way some of the records weren’t as big as we’d hoped. I was disappointed Surrender didn’t happen the way I’d have liked. Of course, you don’t expect everything to be a smash hit when it’s released as a single.”

The accompanying Surrender album, released in July 1971, is one of her most powerful, soulful and cohesive recording projects. Diana’s crystal-clear delivery is stretched, allowing her to cut loose and sing with an abandon she never really had before. The material was meatier and her vocals neatly surf Ashford & Simpson’s stunningly complex arrangements.

I Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You, which features an added writing contribution from Brian Holland, had been recorded by Kiki Dee and Motown recording artist Rita Wright (later more famously billed as Syreeta) in 1967. Diana’s version is much more fully formed, her pleading vocals complementing the floating orchestrations. She also recalls Ain’t No Mountain High Enough by delivering spoken passages that lead to a roaring climax.

Valerie Simpson’s piano work, the prominent bassline, swirling strings and booming horns accompany her, and Diana’s impassioned vocals are purely soulful at the grand, dramatic finale, Valerie describing her ad-libs as being in the stratosphere. Diana had recorded another excellent version of this song back in 1968 and was earmarked for The Supremes’ album Love Child. However, the backing vocals were never completed and didn’t see the light of day until the 2008 release Let The Music Play: Supremes Rarities 1960-1969/Motown Lost & Found. Valerie Simpson was quoted in the liner notes to the Expanded Edition: “It was Nick’s idea to revisit the song.  Sometimes, you almost feel like you missed the mark and you don’t know why but you feel like the song has some potential so you try it again.” 

And If You See Him is outstanding. Valerie described the song as being odd, as it starts in the middle of a sentence and picks up out of nowhere. The song seems to continue in the same softly reflective vein as Remember Me, opening with pulsing guitar and bass notes which sets a tone of urgency. As it leads into the swaying chorus, Diana’s double-tracked vocals rise in power while midway through the second verse she shifts her vocal pitch into the top end of her range. From that point on she sounds as if she’s in constant despair as the track drives into the racing bridge instrumental. Almost becoming manic at points, this merges as a stellar and thoroughly compelling album session, featuring Diana on a soulful high. The track had actually been first cut for Marvin Gaye with the song’s title being And If You See Her though Diana ended up recording her version first.

In Rolling Stone magazine’s review of Surrender in 1971, Russell Gersten took a particular liking to ‘And If You See Him’, highlighting in the article, writing it, “has the poignancy of the great early Motown songs like ‘You Beat Me To The Punch.’  The brilliant, but simple use of rhythm instruments, and the rapid shift of moods perfectly recreate the ambivalence and desperation of someone rejected.” 

The format of Surrender is vaguely similar in its ethos and mood of Diana’s debut solo project. Like that album, the second half settles down into mellower sounds and textures that are brimming with rich and passionate performances. Previously recorded by Gladys Knight & The Pips, Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime swerves narrowly into more gospel-like territory, featuring a highly charged gospel backing on the chorus and Diana’s softer leads on the verses. Yet again the beginning of the track sounds smooth, sensitive, reflective and a little sensuous even and is succeeded by a grand, dazzling crescendo. Valerie wanted to improve upon the version she and Nick had done with Gladys Knight and the Pips, and they felt Diana’s version was better produced. In Billboard’s review of Surrender, they listed Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime, along with the title track and I Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You as being strong contenders for release as a single.

The gently rolling A Simple Thing Like Cry contains another stunning and soulful performance from Diana, ranking this as an exceptional album track. The song builds in tension, and Diana really hits her vocal peak in a track Valerie said encapsulated a jazzy feel. Beginning a subdued style, she lets rip as each of the verses climax into the chorus, demonstrating her true vocal power when she’s allowed to cut free.

Another highlight is served on the stirring, cinematic story-song Did You Read The Morning Paper? which, like A Simple Thing Like Cry, holds a swinging jazz vibe amidst the soulful instrumental. Blending a slamming piano line into the well-crafted jazz flavour, this story-song is beautifully coated by the lush, emotive vocals from Diana. The idea of the storyline concerning a woman’s cheating lover stemmed from Richard Monica’s work for Nancy Wilson on Guess Who I Saw Today. Diana’s interpretive skill really shines on compelling songs such as these.

Far mellower is the dreamy ballad I’ll Settle For You, which intentionally carries a more pop sound and is deceptively simple in melody. Diana displays her unique and effortless flair for ballads here, her enunciation being exquisite, her vocals low, breathy and seamless to then fully accelerating into the top end of her vocal range. The song had first been recorded by female group Candy & The Kisses back in the 1960s on the Scepter label. Valerie Simpson described I’ll Settle For You as “our ‘crossover’ song, in case white radio wanted to play something.  Diana was one of those artists who really did cross over to pop.”

The funky I’m A Winner, the B-side to Surrender, has Las Vegas written all over it. First recorded by Martha Reeves and the Vandellas on their Sugar n Spice album in 1969, Diana bites into the jamming arrangement, giving all she’s got. Her fun, sassy and forceful delivery steadily grows stronger throughout the track, sounding impressively razor sharp as she hits those high notes towards the climax of this belter. Interestingly, after the Martha Reeves & The Vandellas’ original, it was then assigned to Edwin Starr with the backing track made at the same time as Diana’s first solo album. It was only when the sessions for Surrender were under way that it was passed to Diana to record. Billboard magazine also declared this as a highlight of the album in their review.

The album then winds down gently with the glorious All The Befores, which was quite an unusual composition from Ashford & Simpson, though fitted Diana perfectly. Much of Diana’s music has a special, soothing, therapeutic quality, and never more so than on this beautifully delivered ballad, which is nothing short of a masterpiece. The haunting tone is set by a dramatic, classical-like arrangement, with piano and strings leading the way as Diana sings in a more subdued manner, which still emerges as soulful. Her silky yet assertive vocals spiral in front of the music during each verse, flowing seamlessly into the chorus. It’s an excellent end to an essential Diana Ross album.

Surrender is a classic album in the diva’s extensive catalogue, capturing her in strongly emotive voice throughout, complementing Ashford & Simpson’s compositions immensely. Unlike Everything Is Everything, which lacked consistency, this had been carefully conceived as a full studio project and isn’t interrupted by any mediocre fillers. On a personal note, this ranks as one of my favourites by Diana, as her singing is more powerful and engaging than ever; the mood shifts from funky soul to jazzy soul and to out-and-out soul. Excellence all the way.

Although Surrender wasn’t a huge seller in the US, dipping at #56, although did hit the R&B Top 10, sales in the UK were fuelled by the success of the two singles Surrender and Remember Me, elevating it to #10 on the album listing. Incidentally, Surrender was retitled I’m Still Waiting for the British market, to cash in on that track’s chart-topping success that year, even though it had originally been recorded as an additional track for Everything Is Everything.

In late 2008, Surrender was reissued on CD with additional tracks: the delightful Baby I’ll Come (first recorded by Mary Love on the Kent label), Remember Me (Diana! Vocal/undubbed stereo mixed versions and two other alternative mixes); Reach Out I’ll Be There and I Can’t Give Back The Love I Feel For You, both alternate versions and Ain’t No Mountain High Enough and Surrender, both alternative mixes.

In an interview with David Nathan, she spoke about her more powerful singing which she had developed by this time: “A lot of things had happened to me by then. And I’m sure I was probably reflecting that. I had gotten married by then, and I was really going through changes in my life. You know, there are peak points in your life where you’re having a real learning experience and a real change. A lot of things were happening to me in the early 1970s, and I think, in a sense, it was frightening…leaving the girls…but there was a freedom, a freeing of me. It’s just like I was beginning to trust myself more as a singer. I was gaining much more confidence and to trust, and I think that may have shown through, too.”

In late 1971 was the honorary chairman of the Image Awards Presentation. She was also voted number-one entertainer of the year by the NAACP.

Ms. Ross in late 1971 at the Image Awards Presentation in which she was Honorary Chairman

In February 1972, Diana was voted the top female singer of 1971 by readers of the weekly music newspaper Disc & Music Echo. Unable to be interviewed, Diana sent a telegraphed reply: “I’m deeply touched by the honor bestowed upon me being selected Disc & Music Echo‘s World’s Leading Female Singer for 1971. Because I’m winding up the filming of Lady Sings The Blues, I regret not being able to attend the awards presentation. You have my sincere best wishes for a successful affair. Affectionately yours, Diana Ross.”

Ms. Ross having fun on the beach in between filming of Lady Sings The Blues
Rare photo of a pregnant Diana Ross & Berry Gordy

In November 1972, as there were no new studio projects, a compilation simply titled Greatest Hits burst into the UK chart. It contained Diana’s hit singles to date, as well as some outstanding tracks, including And If You See Him, How About You, Didn’t You Know You’d Have To Cry Sometime and (They Long To Be) Close To You.

DIANA ROSS (1970)

Track Listing:

1.  Reach Out And Touch (Somebody’s Hand)

2.  Now That There’s You

3.  You’re All I Need To Get By

4.  These Things Will Keep Me Loving You

5.  Ain’t No Mountain High Enough

6.  Something’s On My Mind

7.  I Wouldn’t Change The Man He is

8.  Keep An Eye

9.  Where There Was Darkness

10. Can’t It Wait Until Tomorrow

11. Dark Side Of The World

Release Date: 19 June 1970   

Motown (MS 711)

Chart Positions: US Billboard R&B #1    Canada #13    UK #14    US Billboard Pop #19

Singles from Diana Ross

Release Date: April 1970

Motown (M 1165)

B-Side: ‘Dark Side of the World’

Chart Positions: US Billboard R&B #7    US Cash Box #10    US Billboard Adult Contemporary #18    US Billboard Pop #20    Canada #23    UK #33    Australia #56

Release Date: July 1970

Motown (M 1169)

B-Side: ‘Can’t It Wait Until Tomorrow’

Chart Positions: US Billboard Pop #1    US Billboard R&B #1    US Cash Box #1    UK #6    US Billboard Adult Contemporary #6    Canada #7    Ireland #14    Australia #25

Year-end Charts (1970): US Billboard Pop #6    US Billboard R&B #16    Canada #97

As soon as Diana Ross left The Supremes to embark on a high-profile solo career, the media inevitably hyped up supposed competition between her and The “New” Supremes (which is how they were known for a short time after Diana’s exit). Fans also seemed divided as to which act to support.

Indeed, Diana opened her very first solo engagements with the words: “Good Evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the let’s-see-if-Diana Ross-can-make-it-alone show” which was greeted with both laughter and rapturous applause. While cynics speculated she would fail as a solo act, Diana need not have worried. Leaving the number-one girl group of all time may have been a huge gamble, but it marked the beginning of something even bigger.

Ms. Ross performing at the Eden Roc Hotel in Miami Beach, Florida. [Friday 13 March 1970]

Her first solo engagements at the Eden Roc Hotel in Miami Beach, Florida, were a success in March 1970 while selling out at the prestigious Waldorf-Astoria in New York every single night for the entire three-week run in September 1970. No expense was spared with the ritzy presentation, Berry Gordy investing over a hundred thousand dollars on the show, which included eight dazzling costume changes, three background singers called The Blackberries, two male dancers and a set that included pop and rhythm-and-blues numbers such as a compulsory Supremes medley, ‘Jesus Christ Superstar’, ‘Don’t Rain On My Parade’ and the Leading Lady medley from the G.I.T On Broadway TV special the previous year in which she had starred alongside The Supremes and The Temptations.

Reviews of the show were quite mixed at first. Her opening act, ventriloquist Willie Tyler, recalled to author J. Randy Taraborelli: “It was as if she had gotten a bad reputation just by leaving the Supremes behind. Also, I think she was trying too hard. Now, she had to prove herself, prove that her ability warranted a solo career, and so she was singing, dancing, changing clothes, doing everything she could think of to razzle-dazzle. I recall her being very disappointed by the reception. Berry told her to take her time and wait it out. Soon, he said, the audiences will come to her side.”

Ms. Ross performing at The Ambassador Hotel’s Coconut Grove nightclub in Los Angeles, California – 30 July 1970

Diana also appeared on the front cover of Ebony magazine, the article heading Why Diana Ross Left The Supremes. In this interview Ms.Ross admitted that this was a daunting move for her: “You know how a runner has somebody to pace him?  Well, Mary [Wilson] and I have been pacing each other for years.  Now, out on my own and without anybody to pace with, it may be a problem for me…” Berry Gordy, on the other hand, was far more confident, telling the media: “She’s not really taking a big chance because people are buying her like mad. Vegas is buying her, Miami is buying her, the Waldorf in New York. Like the stock market, she’s up now because everything she’s done has been a total success. If Diana is going to do it, she’s going to be the best out there. She will be sensational if she does nothing but stand up there and sing.”

Ebony photo session

Back in September 1969, when still officially a Supreme, Diana was teamed with producer Bones Howe. Under his guidance she recorded four excellent tracks, namely Laura Nyro’s ‘Time And Love’ (originally intended as Diana’s debut solo single at one point, it was later rerecorded by The Supremes for their Touch album in 1971, using the exact same backing track as Diana’s, and then rerecorded by Barbra Streisand); ‘Stoney End’ (a Top 10 hit for Ms. Streisand); the endearing ‘The Interim’, written by Jimmy Webb, and the enchanting ‘Love, Lines, Angles And Rhymes’. These all contained excellent vocals from Diana and were all, musically, miles apart from anything she had recorded with The Supremes. Howes had also made instrumental tracks for ‘Ooo Baby Baby’ and ‘Raindrops Keep Falling On My Head’, although at the time of writing this, no vocals from Diana have been found.

Diana’s then-manager, Shelly Berger, was quoted in the CD notes for the 2002 reissue of Diana Ross: “I’d known Bones for a while, and he was very hot at the time, particularly with The 5th Dimension. The thought was we should go outside the company to do something completely different for Diana’s first album.”

Richard Avedon photo session for 1970 issue of French Vogue.
Richard Avedon photo session for 1970 issue of French Vogue.
Richard Avedon photo session for 1970 issue of French Vogue.

As these tracks steered so far away from her style and sound with The Supremes, even though undoubtedly showcasing her versatility and were by far the most mature songs she had recorded at this point, Berry Gordy knew this solo project was so vital. He knew it was imperative at this crucial stage in her career not to alienate Diana’s public. Deciding to play it safe, Berry called upon the ever-reliable Nick Ashford and Valerie Simpson to be at the creative helm.

As Diana said to black music journalist and author David Nathan: “Berry called them in. They in turn started planning the album. I wasn’t checked in with, like, which songs do you want to have? And all that kind of thing. They just put together the songs, and we went in and did the album. I just loved working with the two of them.”

Berry told Ashford & Simpson he wanted a little diversion from the Motown sound but needed material that would bring her to the foreground as a solo artist. The pressure was definitely on to deliver. Valerie Simpson remembered that all eyes seemed to be on her and Nick: they knew failure wasn’t an option.

On 20 and 21 January 1970, Ashford & Simpson, in an inspired creative burst, came up with the following tracks: ‘Reach Out And Touch (Somebody’s Hand)’, ‘Keep An Eye’, ‘Something’s On My Mind’ and ‘Dark Side Of The World’, which Valerie Simpson said were universal songs. Diana was immediately captivated by ‘Reach Out And Touch’ as it was a sing-along song with a lasting effect. During a visit to her home town of Detroit, Diana became alarmed (and equally dismayed) at the rising level of poverty, urban decay and the escalating drug problem. She felt strongly about ‘Reach Out And Touch’ because of its universal lyrics, conveying perfectly how she felt about the problems with the youth culture, which she infinitely believed could be solved if people started caring about each other.

Diana insisted upon this be her all-important debut solo single. Despite her good-hearted intentions, it’s a fairly mundane song with a waltzing rhythm that completely defects from the ever-compulsive Motown sound. Yet its anthem-like qualities most definitely grow on you, and Diana’s touching, angelic-sounding performance is so sweet, heartfelt and genuine that it’s nearly impossible to find any fault with the now-legendary recording. A glossy mixture of pop, soul, folk and gospel, Diana delivers a strong, incisive vocal, and her ad-libs towards the end convey a far more commanding quality in her voice that hadn’t been there before with The Supremes.

In April 1970, it was released as her first single, backed with ‘Dark Side Of The World’ as the flip. To tie-in with its release, Diana appeared on the front cover of Cash Box magazine.

Critics were eager to see whether the “New” Supremes or Diana Ross would win the chart battle. Unfortunately, ‘Reach Out And Touch’ wasn’t the big hit everyone expected. In America, it struggled to #20 on Billboard magazine’s Pop chart though fared better on the R&B listing by peaking at #7. In the UK, the single stalled at a meagre #33, which was a huge let-down. After all, this was the lady who had topped the charts twelve times as the lead singer of The Supremes.

Ebony photo session in 1970

To make matter worse, The New Supremes’ ‘Up The Ladder To The Roof’ totally wiped the floor with ‘Reach Out And Touch (Somebody’s Hand)’ shooting into the Top 10 on both sides of the Atlantic. At this point, a question mark still hung over Diana’s solo career as far as critics were concerned while her detractors revelled in what they saw as an abject failure. Regardless of this mediocre start, Diana’s debut has since risen in status as a true classic, remaining a significant highlight of her concerts throughout her long career, in which she enticed her audiences to hold hands and sway and sing along with her.

Richard Avedon photo session for 1970 issue of French Vogue.

Her second single, however, brought the commercial success she had become accustomed to with The Supremes: the rip-roaring pop/soul blockbuster ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’. Ashford & Simpson came up with this perfect masterpiece by completely dismantling and re-arranging the version Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell had taken high up the chart in 1967. Given that Tammi Terrell passed away, tragically, that year, Diana was sceptical at first, though on hearing the radical new arrangement, her reservations cleared and she conceded to record it.

Nick Ashford was quoted in the book The Billboard Book of Number One R&B Hits, “At that time, lengthy records were starting to come out: six, seven minutes.  We didn’t have any songs like that, but we wanted Diana to feel she was into new things.  We thought to stretch ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’ and we thought how sexy and silky her voice was.”

The track marked a startling fusion of a highly-charged gospel arrangement, by Paul Riser, with a rousing classical music slant, provided by the Detroit Symphony Orchestra, giving the recording a grand, highly theatrical feel. Paul Riser recalled to Billboard: “We cut the rhythm track in Detroit.  The strings and horns were a little too sophisticated for the players there, so we went to New York to do it, to get the best possible performance.” Diana delivers engaging spoken passages in a gloriously sensual voice as the shimmering music, and soaring gospel backing vocals gradually build to an orgasmic climax, where the song’s title is finally and triumphantly sung. Diana’s voice surfboards over the dramatic tidal wave, backed by a thunderous bass line and blaring horns, making for a goose-bump ride that’s still magnificent to this day!

Harry Langdon photo session, 1970

.

Berry Gordy didn’t like the version that much when he heard it, particularly the spoken introduction. Ashford & Simpson intended this to be Diana’s first single, but he was too apprehensive about the song and held it back. However, once radio DJs started playing it, the recording was released as a single. The full version featured on her eponymous debut album clocked in at over six minutes long, but for the single, it was edited to the standard three and a half minutes. Nonetheless, it retained its full bombastic effect. Michael Thomas later wrote in Rolling Stone magazine: “That record, ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough,’ is one of the ten best singles ever made. Diana Ross, when she talks on a record in that petulant dirty whisper, could sell me anything. Diana’s solo records, under the direction of her new handlers Nick Ashford and Valerie Simpson, are some of the most gloriously melodramatic virtuoso pop since Phil Spector did the Righteous Brothers.” 

Harry Langdon photo session, 1970

Lifted in July 1970, the single met with wide critical acclaim, Billboard predicting: “This heavy updating of the past Marvin Gaye-Tammi Terrell hit will prove a sales and chart topper for her first smash.”  They were spot on: The single rapidly hit pole position on both the US pop and R&B charts, to become her first solo chart-topper and first solo million-seller, shifting well over 1.2 million copies in America alone.

Success in the UK was assured; who could honestly resist this? Ain’t No Mountain High Enough raced to #6, heralding the start of a permanent love relationship with the British public. The song also became the first in a long line of Grammy Award nominations. In fact it seems a travesty that this epic masterpiece didn’t win any awards but at the same time anyone who had any doubts Diana Ross couldn’t survive without The Supremes were silenced. Diana Ross the solo star had arrived! Around this time, she graced the cover of Record Mirror and headlined at the Carter Barron Amphitheater under the title The Diana Ross Show.

Record Mirror photo session – 30 June 1970

There were (surprisingly) no other singles issued from her superb debut album (simply titled Diana Ross) which was released in June 1970 (charting at the same time as The “New” Supremes’ debut Right On, and Diana’s farewell performance from the group, released as a double-LP) but that’s not to say there weren’t any other tracks worthy of single release. For instance, a spine-tingling version of Marvin and Tammi’s ‘You’re All I Need To Get By’ proved a great experiment for the new and more powerful Diana Ross sound. The depth, character and drama in her voice pour out on this terrific number, and her version stands, arguably, as the definitive reading. Given a slow-burning approach, the rhythm rises to a stunning climax, Diana’s vocals really hitting their full potential as the arrangement crackles with intensity. The repetitive bass line and bluesy feel are engrossed in a hypnotic style, with a backdrop of dreamy, gospel-infused backing vocals.

Harry Langdon photo session, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session, 1970

The joyous ‘Now That There’s You’ is another commercially slanted number that remained hidden away on the album. Like ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’, Diana talk-sings through the duration of each verse, before the chorus kicks in, during which she’s backed by a string of gospel harmonies. Ultimately a feel-good number, Diana sways from moments of yearning vulnerability to shining self-assurance in full command of her new vocal style and providing some arresting ad-libs in the last minute of the song. She sounded relaxed and confident throughout the recording and you could hear significant progress as a vocalist. First recorded by Valerie Simpson in 1969, it was later included on her Exposed album in 1971 and used the same backing track as was used for Diana’s. In their review of Diana Ross, Billboard magazine hailed this as one of the stand-out tracks.

Harry Langdon photo session, 1970

Recorded when she was still with The Supremes, ‘These Things Will Keep Me Loving You’ doesn’t actually include Mary Wilson or Cindy Birdsong. The track was originally intended as Diana’s swansong with the trio, but was sidestepped for ‘Someday We’ll Be Together’. It was then scheduled to be her solo debut, but when Diana was adamant ‘Reach Out And Touch (Somebody’s Hand)’ be her first, it was again put on the backburner. By the time her first single had dipped out of the charts, DJs became interested in ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’, so any plans for ‘These Things Will Keep Me Loving You’ being released as a single were shelved.

Interestingly, this was the only song here not written by Ashford & Simpson; the credits read Johnny Bristol (who worked with Diana on ‘Someday We’ll Be Together’) and Harvey Fuqua. Without a doubt this would have been a huge smash if released as a single. That pure Motown sound is evident on the bouncy arrangement, complemented by Diana’s crisp, subdued performance. Some brief backing vocals interludes from Johnny Bristol and gospel harmonies all add to the fire and soulful flavour. As Motown fans know, The Velvelettes recorded the original version in 1966; it represented their third American smash and their only British hit upon its release in 1971.

While the first half of the album holds a commercial quality, the second half is lost amidst a dark and swirling mood, although it begins with the relatively light mid-tempo ‘Something’s On My Mind’. First recorded by Rita Wright (later known as Syreeta) in 1968, Diana’s delivery is refreshing and soulful. Her diction and phrasing is both immaculate and emotive, singing the song with real clarity.

She sounds more brassy and playful on another incredibly contagious number ‘I Wouldn’t Change The Man He Is’. Previously recorded by Blinky Williams back in 1968, the track holds a bluesy feel that encapsulates a swinging and immediately striking jazz-like vibe. Here, Diana is able to cut loose at the bridge, revealing a new confidence in her voice and delivering a tour-de-force performance. These numbers really captured the top end of her vocal range, exactly what Ashford & Simpson were striving for. Never before had she sounded so strong vocally, alternating between a low, subdued and breathy style, to pushing right up to the maximum of her vocal abilities.

Harry Langdon photo session, 1970

‘Keep An Eye’ sends a shiver down the spine as the mood darkens and becomes more sombre and mellow. The song depicts a bitter tale of paranoia and infidelity, which she had previously recorded on The Supremes’ album Love Child. This solo version is more fully formed, holding more fire and flair, and is far more dramatic. The funk-driven rhythm section is highlighted by Diana’s chilly, almost detached, textured delivery as she glides across the musical landscapes with her interpretive craft.

Harry Langdon photo session, 1970

‘Where There Was Darkness’ is hauntingly beautiful, with a divine and passionate performance from Diana. Although the strings at the intro sound odd and distorted (this wailing, ghostly sound is also repeated at the bridge), it leads into an arrangement that drifts along compellingly, before changing tempo as it brings us into the chorus.

Even more dreamy and mellow is the gorgeous ‘Can’t It Wait Until Tomorrow’, which remains mostly calm as it sails along smoothly, leading to an understated saxophone interlude at the bridge. Not the most exciting track on the album to be fair, but certainly continues the high calibre fare, Diana’s vocals sounding like a forerunner to her foray into jazz with Lady Sings The Blues. This track also appeared as the flip side to the number-one hit ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’.

Michael Ochs photo session for Harper’s Bazaar magazine, 1970

The project then winds down with the spellbinding ‘Dark Side Of The World’. This song had first been cut by The Velvelettes in 1967 under the title ‘Bring Back The Sunshine’ before Ashford & Simpson completely transformed the arrangement for Marvin Gaye in 1969 (although his take would remain unreleased for several years). Diana’s version is completely immersed in the stirring, atmospheric and soulful arrangement, delivering one of her most impressive vocal performances on the album, the track itself most definitely a highlight. With swirling strings and a distinctly sombre feel, this serves as a superb end to a thoroughly compelling album.

Overall, the Diana Ross album is a thrilling debut, drawing mostly positive reviews from critics, and this has since gone on to be lauded as some of her most stunning solo work. A fantastic start to Diana’s solo career, and something of an underrated masterpiece to say the very least! It stands as an artistic statement, letting the world know that Diana Ross the solo star was a force to be reckoned with.

The album’s startling front cover shows Diana dressed as a child, wearing cut-off shorts and T-shirt, holding an apple and gazing into the air with an impish grin on her face…a far cry from the glamorous diva we all know and love. According to Harry Langdon, the photograph was intended to go back to basics, stripping her of the showbiz trappings, to reflect her humble beginnings in Detroit. When Berry Gordy had summoned Langdon to his office demanding to know what on earth the logic was behind the photo session, he explained to Mr. Gordy: “Diana Ross has been so successful with all of the extremely fortunate people in the world, I wondered what it would be like to appeal to her own people? The black people in the projects and the people who don’t have the money to see her perform? The people who can only buy her records? Here, in my photo of her, she looks like one of the masses. She’s one of them.” After all, she was in effect starting again as a soloist and had to prove herself all over again. Years later, in 2007, during an interview with Gay Times magazine , Diana was asked to name her favourite album sleeve and replied that it was her solo debut.

Harry Langdon photo session for her debut solo album, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session for her debut solo album, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session for her debut solo album, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session for her debut solo album, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session for her debut solo album, 1970
Harry Langdon photo session for her debut solo album, 1970

Diana Ross wasn’t quite the blockbusting success it deserved to be although it was a strong seller, later certified Gold by the RIAA in the US. It peaked in the US chart at #19 while topping the R&B chart. It was also a well-deserved Top 20 success in the UK, where it peaked at #14.

Michael Ochs photo session for Harper’s Bazaar magazine, 1970

On 26 March 2002, when Diana celebrated her fifty-eighth birthday, this was rereleased to include the original Bones Howe sessions. It also boasted a live version of ‘Something’s On My Mind’, recorded at the The Grove in Los Angeles on 7 August 1970 and alternate mixes of ‘These Things Will Keep Me Loving You’ and ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’. There’s also an alternate vocal of ‘Now That There’s You’. Following its welcome reissue, the album garnered even more glowing reviews than it had upon its original release.

Critical reaction to her solo debut has been mostly positive over the years with AllMusic Guide hailing this as being her most stunning work during her Motown era. Robert Christgau in his review for Village Voice was less enthused, writing: “The sound of young America grows older, replacing momentum with progress and exuberance with nuanced cool. Producers Nick Ashford and Valerie Simpson provide all but one of the songs–they’ve written a couple of great ones for Marvin & Tammi in the past. Unfortunately, the same couple (of songs) provide two of the three high spots here. And there ain’t no high spot high enough.” Billboard magazine was far more complimentary, writing “Diana Ross is as potent on the solo trail as she was when leading the Supremes.”

On 1 October 1970, Diana appeared on The Merv Griffin Show for performances of ‘Reach Out And Touch (Somebody’s Hand)’ and ‘Ain’t No Mountain High Enough’, plus an interview.

In an interview with David Nathan for Blues & Soul magazine, Diana reflected on her first year as a solo artist: “I spent ten years building a name, you know…an image…and we became successful. But it was a change that just had to happen. I couldn’t have stayed where I was. The fear was, you know, will I be okay? Will my records be hits? People had done some of the same things and weren’t successful. Mary Wells left Motown and went to other companies and tried, and nothing materialised. I think the same thing (happened) with Florence Ballard. When she left, she was going to get married and have children, and then she went to other record companies. When you make a decision to split, you need to take responsibility that you’ve caused and created whatever happens.”

Michael Ochs photo session for Harper’s Bazaar magazine, 1970
 Photographed by Lawrence Schiller in Central Park, 1970
Photographed by Lawrence Schiller in Central Park, 1970
Photographed by Lawrence Schiller in Central Park, 1970
Photographed by Lawrence Schiller in Central Park, 1970

The following videos are from the Merv Griffin Show in 1970